Why Nobody Trusts a Store that Looks “Too New”

Collaborative Post

There’s something funny that happens when people land on a brand-new online store. You’d think they’d be excited, right? Like, it’s a new business that will hopefully go smoothly in the near future, there’s so many fresh products, you can count on cute branding, yeah, all of that. But no, people get suspicious. Which, maybe in your place as the customer, you might have an understanding. So, there’s this weird little switch in their brain that goes something like “ Okay, yeah, this looks… too new.” Like, maybe the website is just too empty. Basically, new websites have the “just opened five minutes ago in someone’s living room” feel.

Sure, new is fine, but there are some prejudices at the same time, too. So yeah, once they get that feeling, it’s really hard to pull them back in. And yeah, by all means here, it’s almost unfair, honestly. New brands try so hard, and people still scroll around with caution. So what gives here?

People Expect a New Store to Already have a Reputation

Yeah, that’s way too absurd, isn’t it? The wild part is that shoppers want two things at the same time, and neither of them makes sense together. Maybe as a shopper, you might be guilty of this as well. So, they want new brands, they love discovering new products, they love saying “oh, I found this small shop before it blew up”, but they also want that same store to already have hundreds of reviews, photos, testimonials, and everything in place. Basically, they want “brand new” and “established” at the exact same time. And yeah, that’s impossible.

So when a store looks too fresh, people hesitate. Now, it’s not exactly because the products look bad or the branding is off, but it’s simply because the store hasn’t existed long enough to collect social proof. Humans just don’t trust empty spaces. Even online. Especially online.

A “Too New” Storefront Feels Like it’s Missing the Basics

Shoppers have certain expectations now, and when those things aren’t there, they immediately assume the worst. They want policies clearly displayed. They want FAQs. They want product photos from every angle. And of course, they want smooth navigation, easy checkout, clean layout, and all the little elements that quietly signal professionalism. If any of that is missing, even slightly, people get nervous fast. You would get nervous too if you were on a website and noticed that it was lacking the very basics, wouldn’t you?

So, if you’re running a Shopify website, you’re at least in for luck, because there’s a lot of options out there, be it using a professional Shopify development service to help you out, but of course, there’s plenty of templates and tutorial videos if you’d rather DIY it. But you’re absolutely better off letting a professional do the work, especially if you literally have zero experience with web design and UX.

A New Store has to Feel Established Before it Actually Is

But that doesn’t sound fair at all, right? Well, yeah, honestly, that’s the tricky part. So, a store that’s only been live for two weeks still has to feel like it’s been around for years. It has to present confidence before it even earns it. So, it has to look trustworthy before there’s any history to back it up. Basically, everything needs to feel complete, even if the brand is literally on day one.

And yeah, that’s the challenge no one talks about. And of course, new business has to skip the awkward beginner phase and show up online looking like they already know the rules. Because shoppers don’t care how long the store has existed. They care how long it feels like it has existed.

Customers Want Proof that Somebody Else Already “Went First”

Well, you need to keep in mind that people don’t like being the first buyer. Well, at least online, they don’t really like the idea of doing that. They really don’t. They don’t want to test the quality for the group. They don’t want to be the one who discovers the shipping is slow or the product doesn’t match the pictures.

Plus, it doesn’t help that there’s a lot of scammers who use Shopify and then take people's card info. Nowadays, there’s drop shipping; nowadays, theres fake AI images online. Nowadays, scams are getting trickier. They want someone else to deal with all that. So when a store is new and doesn’t have much history yet, customers pull back purely from fear of being the first person to trust it. Even something small like one review, one customer photo or one Instagram tag can make the entire store seem more legitimate.

It only takes a tiny bit of proof to calm people down. But those early days, before any of that exists, feel rough. Because yeah, a new store has to convince people to take a chance when their instincts are saying no.

—End of collaborative post—

✨ New Series: How to Become an Early Riser

Discover key methods to make early rising a habit
How to wake up early + energized every morning
Morning routines for health + success

View Series Playlist

Free self-development courses
👇

Tap on any of the courses below to start learning how to:

boost your productivity (withGTD),
get focused (with Deep Work),
design a successful + fulfilling life (with The 7 Habits course),
or learn the art of influencing others (with the How to Win Friends & Influence People course.)